They say, 鈥楧on鈥檛 learn safety by accident.鈥� But that seems to be the way we do it in India.
Last year, Mumbai witnessed a stampede-like situation near Lower Parel station鈥攚hich witnesses a footfall of nearly 150,000 every day鈥攁s the Western Railway closed the road-over-bridge (RoB), citing an audit report by IIT-B, which deemed the structure unfit owing to corrosion. But there was no concrete dispersal plan for pedestrians and vehicles and no signage or officials to direct the crowd. What鈥檚 more, torrential downpour in July 2018 saw the collapse of the Gokhale RoB at Andheri station, which served as a pedestrian-accessible connection between the bustling east and west sides of Andheri. Other mishaps in the financial capital this year include the Mumbai CST foot-over-bridge collapse and the bridge crash at the Vashi Mini Seashore site.
Mumbai is not alone鈥擪olkata and Varanasi, among others, have witnessed similar mishaps. In fact, Kolkata has recorded three major bridge collapses in five years: Ultadanga Flyover (2013), Vivekananda Flyover (2016), and Majerhat Bridge (2018).
Systemic failures?
Art critic and social thinker once said, 鈥淨uality is never an accident. It is always the result of an intelligent effort.鈥� 聽So have we lacked the requisite efforts when it comes to bridges?
Challenges in old bridges mostly arise from lack of availability of drawings, deterioration of material properties over time, and increase in loading since the time they were built.
According to聽railway expert Vivek Sood, 鈥淚ndian Railways has a comprehensive system of inspections, carried out periodically at different levels, and special checks are done occasionally if warranted.鈥� However, for many bridges, regular checks and retrofitting of existing structures are crucial. 鈥淭his is an area that cannot be over-emphasised, not just in India but world over,鈥� he adds. 鈥淭here will always be old bridges. Inspection techniques, retrofitting techniques and health monitoring are important. The concept of load rating also requires a lot of work to ensure bridges give good service.鈥� 聽
To keep a regular check on bridges, though, we first need a record of them.聽Chetan R Raikar, Chairman and Managing Director, Structwel Designers and Consultants,聽says,听鈥�The Central Government is preparing an inventory of the total number of bridges on the National Highways along with condition assessment.鈥� Structwel has been involved in assessment and testing of bridges for over three decades.
As per rough estimates, there could be about 2.5 lakh bridges on the National Highways. Maharashtra itself has over 15,000 state highway bridges. So across 33 states, there could be another 3.5 lakh state highway bridges. Put together, one can roughly consider 6 lakh bridges in the country, along with private bridges like jetties and others. And that is a huge inventory to maintain.
Evidently, managing bridges requires a system. 鈥淭he system should collate all data from various types of bridges and try to assist human inspections with analytics gained from previous inspections and previous history,鈥� suggests Sood. Such a system could identify problems early, with adequate time to address underlying issues.
SHRIYAL SETHUMADHAVAN
