SC criticises Arbitral Award, calls fresh hearing on SE Railway dispute
24 Jan 2024
2 Min Read
CW Team
The Supreme Court strongly criticised an arbitral award instructing the South Eastern Railway to pay Rs 13.01 billion to a private firm, asserting that such misuse of public funds cannot be tolerated. The bench, led by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, expressed initial dissatisfaction with the sole arbitrator's decision, stating, "Less said the better. As judges, we also know a lot of things."
Expressing discontent with the arbitral award, the Chief Justice remarked, "I am not happy with the arbitral award. Let the case go before a dispassionate arbitrator and let this be heard again. If Railways lose there... then it is fine. But, the arbitration process cannot be allowed to be handled like this. This is why the arbitration is getting a bad name."
Emphasising the need to prevent the mismanagement of public funds, the bench stated, "The public money cannot be allowed to go waste like this."
The case pertains to the South Eastern Railway's challenge against the arbitral award favouring Kolkata-based firm Rashmi Metaliks Limited in a contractual dispute.
Despite the Supreme Court's initial reluctance to proceed, it scheduled the hearing for Thursday and directed senior advocate Abhishek Singhvi, representing the private firm, to obtain instructions.
Previously, the Calcutta High Court had granted an "unconditional stay" on the enforcement of the arbitration award, citing "glaring irregularities."
Referring to the observations made by the high court, the Chief Justice stated, "Look at what the high court has observed. We are willing to set aside the order and have a fresh arbitration. We will appoint an arbitrator for this one."
The Supreme Court strongly criticised an arbitral award instructing the South Eastern Railway to pay Rs 13.01 billion to a private firm, asserting that such misuse of public funds cannot be tolerated. The bench, led by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, expressed initial dissatisfaction with the sole arbitrator's decision, stating, Less said the better. As judges, we also know a lot of things.
Expressing discontent with the arbitral award, the Chief Justice remarked, I am not happy with the arbitral award. Let the case go before a dispassionate arbitrator and let this be heard again. If Railways lose there... then it is fine. But, the arbitration process cannot be allowed to be handled like this. This is why the arbitration is getting a bad name.
Emphasising the need to prevent the mismanagement of public funds, the bench stated, The public money cannot be allowed to go waste like this.
The case pertains to the South Eastern Railway's challenge against the arbitral award favouring Kolkata-based firm Rashmi Metaliks Limited in a contractual dispute.
Despite the Supreme Court's initial reluctance to proceed, it scheduled the hearing for Thursday and directed senior advocate Abhishek Singhvi, representing the private firm, to obtain instructions.
Previously, the Calcutta High Court had granted an unconditional stay on the enforcement of the arbitration award, citing glaring irregularities.
Referring to the observations made by the high court, the Chief Justice stated, Look at what the high court has observed. We are willing to set aside the order and have a fresh arbitration. We will appoint an arbitrator for this one.
Next Story
Blum India brings Design Reverie to Hyderabad
Blum India hosted the Hyderabad edition of its signature event, Design Reverie, at the historic Taj Falaknuma Palace, making it a memorable evening for the city鈥檚 architecture and interior design community. As per news reports, the event combined modern design sensibilities with the grandeur of a palace setting and the spiritual charm of Sufi qawwali.This marked the third edition of the event, after previous gatherings in Delhi and Bangalore. In Hyderabad, the focus was on fostering relaxed yet meaningful dialogue among design professionals鈥攁way from the typical conference setup. The eveni..
Next Story
Hafele launches Platinum Studio in Nagpur
Hafele has expanded its franchise footprint in central India by opening a new Studio Partner Platinum showroom in Nagpur in collaboration with Onkar Furnitech. The studio was inaugurated by Nitin Gadkari, Minister of Road Transport and Highways, along with Padma Gupta, Director 鈥� HR & Customer Experience, Hafele South Asia.Located at Sarthak Plaza, South Ambazari Road, Laxmi Nagar, the showroom offers an immersive experience of Hafele鈥檚 wide-ranging interior and home solutions. Designed as a hands-on, real-life application space, the studio showcases Hafele鈥檚 full portfolio鈥攊ncludi..
Next Story
Truflo by Hindware wins GPTW honour again
Truflo by Hindware has been certified a Great Place to Work for the fourth consecutive year, reaffirming its commitment to a people-first culture. The certification was awarded by the Great Place to Work Institute following a rigorous evaluation of employee experience, leadership, culture, and HR practices.Known as India鈥檚 fastest-growing plastic pipes and fittings company, Truflo has focused on fostering an inclusive, innovative, and growth-driven work environment. The company prioritises employee well-being and professional development, creating a culture where people feel valued and empow..
