Bombay HC upholds Godrej Properties & Shelton Infra plot retention
23 Feb 2024
2 Min Read
CW Team
In Sanpada, Navi Mumbai, two plots that were initially won in bids by Godrej Properties and Shelton Infrastructure faced allotment cancellation by Cidco. However, the Bombay High Court, in its judgment on February 12, criticised Cidco's decision last October, deeming it "irrational," "clearly arbitrary," and influenced by "irrelevant and external considerations." The court noted that Cidco deliberately ignored the binding orders of the court.
The 13 plots in Navi Mumbai were part of two schemes for residential and commercial use, for which Cidco had floated tenders in February 2021. Despite Cidco's attempt to cancel the allotments and issue fresh bids through an interim plea, the High Court rejected the request. Subsequently, in October, Cidco issued an order cancelling the allotments to prevent a supposed loss to the public exchequer due to "artificial depression." Godrej and Shelton challenged this cancellation by filing petitions before the High Court.
The High Court observed that Cidco did not cancel the allotments of other bidders who agreed to pay the 'delayed payment charges' demanded by the corporation. Represented by senior counsels Milind Sathe and Samit Shukla of DSK Legal, Godrej, and Shelton, represented by advocate Bindi Dave and Wadia Ghandy, argued that the cancellation was discriminatory and violated their fundamental right to equality. The division bench of Justices Gautam Patel and Kamal Khata concurred, labeling it as discriminatory and emphasized that Cidco should act diligently and not attempt to overreach the court. The court, in its judgment, uploaded, stressed that as a body dealing with public funds, Cidco should adhere strictly to the boundaries of the law.
The issue of the bid had faced legal challenges previously, where the bidders had successfully navigated the legal waters. Concerned that the controversy over lands in Navi Mumbai, involving disputes between Cidco and Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation (NMMC), could impact them, Godrej, Shelton, and other successful bidders sought relief from the High Court in 2021. The municipal corporation had been denying development permission, claiming that the plots were reserved for various proposed public purposes.
In Sanpada, Navi Mumbai, two plots that were initially won in bids by Godrej Properties and Shelton Infrastructure faced allotment cancellation by Cidco. However, the Bombay High Court, in its judgment on February 12, criticised Cidco's decision last October, deeming it irrational, clearly arbitrary, and influenced by irrelevant and external considerations. The court noted that Cidco deliberately ignored the binding orders of the court.
The 13 plots in Navi Mumbai were part of two schemes for residential and commercial use, for which Cidco had floated tenders in February 2021. Despite Cidco's attempt to cancel the allotments and issue fresh bids through an interim plea, the High Court rejected the request. Subsequently, in October, Cidco issued an order cancelling the allotments to prevent a supposed loss to the public exchequer due to artificial depression. Godrej and Shelton challenged this cancellation by filing petitions before the High Court.
The High Court observed that Cidco did not cancel the allotments of other bidders who agreed to pay the 'delayed payment charges' demanded by the corporation. Represented by senior counsels Milind Sathe and Samit Shukla of DSK Legal, Godrej, and Shelton, represented by advocate Bindi Dave and Wadia Ghandy, argued that the cancellation was discriminatory and violated their fundamental right to equality. The division bench of Justices Gautam Patel and Kamal Khata concurred, labeling it as discriminatory and emphasized that Cidco should act diligently and not attempt to overreach the court. The court, in its judgment, uploaded, stressed that as a body dealing with public funds, Cidco should adhere strictly to the boundaries of the law.
The issue of the bid had faced legal challenges previously, where the bidders had successfully navigated the legal waters. Concerned that the controversy over lands in Navi Mumbai, involving disputes between Cidco and Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation (NMMC), could impact them, Godrej, Shelton, and other successful bidders sought relief from the High Court in 2021. The municipal corporation had been denying development permission, claiming that the plots were reserved for various proposed public purposes.
Next Story
Postal Dept Unveils Stamp Honouring 125 Years of Kodaikanal Observatory
The Department of Posts is proud to release a commemorative postage stamp celebrating 125 years of the Kodaikanal Solar Observatory (KSO). Recognising the legacy of the KSO through this special stamp is a fitting tribute to one of India鈥檚 most significant scientific institutions and highlights the nation鈥檚 long-standing contribution to global science.The Commemorative stamp was released by S Rajendra Kumar, Chief Postmaster General, Karnataka Circle in the gracious presence of A S Kiran Kumar, Chairperson, Governing Council, IIA and Former Chairman, ISRO and other esteemed guests at Indian..
Next Story
IIFT Sets Up First Overseas Campus and Expands Global Reach in Dubai
The Indian Institute of Foreign Trade (IIFT), an autonomous body under the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India, has announced the establishment of its first overseas campus in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. This marks a key step in expanding IIFT鈥檚 global presence and strengthening India鈥檚 engagement in international business education.This historic development has been made possible with the approvals from the Ministry of Education, and No Objection Certificates from the Ministry of External Affairs, Ministry of 亚博体育官网首页 Affairs, and the University Grants Commission. It marks..
Next Story
KEC International Bags Rs 11.33 Bn Transmission & Distribution Orders
KEC International, a prominent global infrastructure EPC company and a part of the RPG Group, announced that it had secured new transmission and distribution (T\&D) project orders worth Rs 11.33 billion in India. The company鈥檚 shares were expected to draw attention on Monday, May 19.The newly won orders include a significant contract from Power Grid Corporation of India (PGCIL) for the construction of a 卤800 kV HVDC transmission line along with a 765 kV GIS substation. Additionally, KEC International secured an order from a leading private developer for a 400 kV Quad transmission line.V..