Builders cannot ask for maintenance costs from buyers without OC

07 Feb 2022 CW Team

The apex consumer forum held that homebuyers would be liable to pay maintenance charges for their apartments only after the builder obtains occupancy certificate from the civic authority, and it is not appropriate for builders to demand it even though the home buyers start residing in their apartments after taking over the ownership.

It said if the builder fails to obtain OC then it means that the project is not yet finished and it would be viewed only as 鈥減aper possession鈥� if the flat is handed over to the buyers. The NCDRC permitted a plea of a batch of 15 homebuyers from Benguluru led by Harinder Singh who was compelled by a builder to pay maintenance charges after taking control of their apartments without OC.Their lawyer Chandrachur Bhattacharya claimed before a bench of S M Kanitkar and Binoy Kumar that the buyers were forced to pay two years of maintenance in advance while taking control of the apartments for which the builder failed to obtain OC despite a delay of six years.

Opposing homebuyers鈥� plea, the builder VDB Whitefield Development Private Ltd argued that maintenance cost was being charged as it was providing all facilities to those who have shifted to their flats. It said that delay in the project was caused because of the Covid-19 pandemic, and it was the buyers who had forced it to give them physical ownership of their units without OC.

However, NCDRC was not convinced with the submission of the builders and permitted the plea of homebuyers by relying upon a recent judgment delivered by the Supreme Court in January and an earlier verdict of the Commission.

Also read: Property costs likely to increase by 5-10% in 2022: Anarock

In a relief to homebuyers who are pushed to take possession and start living in their apartments without occupancy certificate (OC) due to delay on the part of builders to get all approvals from the authority, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) held that builders cannot ask for maintenance charge from the buyers without OC. The apex consumer forum held that homebuyers would be liable to pay maintenance charges for their apartments only after the builder obtains occupancy certificate from the civic authority, and it is not appropriate for builders to demand it even though the home buyers start residing in their apartments after taking over the ownership. It said if the builder fails to obtain OC then it means that the project is not yet finished and it would be viewed only as 鈥減aper possession鈥� if the flat is handed over to the buyers. The NCDRC permitted a plea of a batch of 15 homebuyers from Benguluru led by Harinder Singh who was compelled by a builder to pay maintenance charges after taking control of their apartments without OC.Their lawyer Chandrachur Bhattacharya claimed before a bench of S M Kanitkar and Binoy Kumar that the buyers were forced to pay two years of maintenance in advance while taking control of the apartments for which the builder failed to obtain OC despite a delay of six years. Opposing homebuyers鈥� plea, the builder VDB Whitefield Development Private Ltd argued that maintenance cost was being charged as it was providing all facilities to those who have shifted to their flats. It said that delay in the project was caused because of the Covid-19 pandemic, and it was the buyers who had forced it to give them physical ownership of their units without OC. However, NCDRC was not convinced with the submission of the builders and permitted the plea of homebuyers by relying upon a recent judgment delivered by the Supreme Court in January and an earlier verdict of the Commission. Image Source Also read: Property costs likely to increase by 5-10% in 2022: Anarock

Real Estate

21 May 2025

Kolkata鈥檚 luxury housing market sees price growth amid mixed trends

A new study by Nklusive reveals that Kolkata鈥檚 luxury residential market (Rs 5鈥�10 crore) recorded a 33 per cent year-on-year rise in supply and a 52 per cent increase in sales in calendar year 2024 (CY24). South Kolkata led with 78 per cent of the segment鈥檚 supply. The average price rose by 6 per cent鈥攆rom Rs 17,519 to Rs 18,600 per sq ft鈥攚hile unsold inventory grew by 15 per cent. Monthly absorption improved from 2 to 3 units.In contrast, the ultra-luxury segment (Rs 10 crore and above) experienced a 17 per cent decline in supply and a 30 per cent fall in sales. Central Kolkata acco..

Infrastructure Transport

21 May 2025

New Expressway to Cut Pune-Bengaluru Travel Time by Half

The upcoming Pune-Bengaluru Expressway is expected to significantly improve connectivity and economic opportunities across Maharashtra and Karnataka. This 700-kilometre greenfield, access-controlled highway will cut the travel time between Pune and Bengaluru from 15 hours to just 7 hours, facilitating easier movement for both commuters and businesses. Starting from Bommanal in Karnataka鈥檚 Athani Taluk, the expressway will traverse important districts such as Belagavi, Bagalkot, and Jamakhandi. It will then enter Maharashtra at Kanjle, connect with the proposed Pune Ring Road, and pass throug..

Infrastructure Transport

21 May 2025

Nagpur鈥檚 Koradi Naka to Get Y-Shaped Flyover for Safer, Smoother Traffic

To alleviate traffic congestion and enhance safety at Koradi Naka in Nagpur, a Y-shaped flyover is currently being constructed on National Highway 47. Demolition work has already commenced, with the main construction scheduled to start on June 20, 2025.The project, costing Rs 430.37 billion, involves building a 1,090-meter-long flyover that will connect Farsa, the Mahadula Railway Overbridge (ROB), and Bokhara Road, and will also feature an underpass. The existing structure will be repurposed into a service road to facilitate local traffic.Koradi Naka has been identified as a significant "blac..